
Lisa Valentine
Lisa Valentine, a Muslim woman, was arrested and ordered to serve 10 days in jail for contempt of court after refusing to remove her hijab (head scarf). The incident took place in Douglasville, Georgia when Valentine went with a nephew to a traffic citation hearing. She was told she could not be allowed inside the courthouse unless she removed the headscarf.
Valentine exchanged a few words with the official explaining that she had been in courtrooms with her headscarf on before. After the official repeated that she could not enter without removing the item, Valentine turned to leave and in her anger apparently uttered an expletive which rubbed the official the wrong way. He handcuffed her and took her before the judge who charged her with contempt of court and ordered her to spend 10 days in jail.
After Council on American-Islamic Relations, a Washington-based organization, urged federal authorities to investigate the incident, Valentine was released. She has since spoken out about the incident, stating that she felt her civil and human rights were violated; but based on the comments being left on various news websites there are many people who disagree with Valentine’s viewpoint. A quick scan of a few hundred comments about the incident indicate more people believe Valentine had no right to expect the rules to be broken on her account. If head scarfs are not allowed in the courtroom she should not have gone to court if removing her head scarf was against her religion.
On the one hand I can see the point that’s being made. Rules are rules. Granted some rules are arbitrary and the only way to change arbitrary rules is to challenge them. Most people are law abiding. We tend to accept laws without questioning their basis, but some laws are designed to violate the rights of certain people and such laws should not exist. This is not a statement in connection with the Lisa Valentine situation. Let’s face it, laws banning the sale of ice cream sodas on Sundays, laws banning wearing baggy pants, these are examples of laws designed to violate people’s basic human rights. Not all laws are reasonable; but unless challenged, they remain law.
Was Lisa Valentine wrong to try to challenge the official? Many people seem to think she was indeed wrong; but I would suggest that if more people had the courage to challenge rules they don’t agree with we might have a more open, more tolerant society. Instead we have a situation where a judge can throw a woman in jail and order her to serve 10 days because she tried to stand up for what she considered her basic human right. We have a situation where a person given the authority to make an arrest was able to put a woman in handcuffs because he was pissed off that she not only didn’t immediately leave or remove her head scarf when he told her to do one or the other, but she dared curse in his presence on top of it. How dare she think she had any rights? He was the one in uniform, not her. He had the rights, and the judge had the rights. She, a mere citizen, had no rights.
There are two separate issues here and it seems to me that they are being mistakenly entangled. There’s the question of whether or not Lisa Valentine should have been allowed in the courtroom with her hijab on, and there’s the question of whether or not Lisa Valentine’s civil rights were violated when she was arrested and sent to jail basically for annoying the official at the security checkpoint.
If you want to argue that rules are rules, then fine, rules are rules and if there’s a rule that you can’t go into the courtroom with a head scarf, then Lisa Valentine needed to obey the rule because it was in her best interest to do so. From all accounts Lisa was not trying to force her way into the courtroom. After she was told she couldn’t go in, she asked why and expressed displeasure with the decision; but she wasn’t refusing to leave. In fact, it was when she turned to leave that she was put in handcuffs and she was put in handcuffs because she exercised her freedom of speech by uttering a curse word.
The question here is, was she handcuffed and put in jail with an order to serve 10 days for contempt of court because she did something wrong or because the officer and the judge didn’t like her and what she stood for; and should we be applauding when people in power abuse their power just because the victim is someone we ourselves don’t like for whatever reason we don’t like them?