The David Reimer Story
Saturday, December 20th, 2008
I’ve just finished reading about David Reimer, the Canadian who was born a boy but got sexually reassigned and raised as a girl until he stopped identifying as female at the age of 14. It’s all very fascinating and disturbing at the same time. According to what I’ve read, David Reimer’s penis was accidentally burned off beyond surgical repair during an attempt at a newfangled method of circumcision when he was 8 months old. His parents were worried about what kind of future he was going to have, not having a penis, so they took him to see a psychologist who had some pretty interesting ideas about gender identity.
John Money, the psychologist the Reimer’s consulted, believed that gender identity is learned. In other words the things that make us male or female, with the exception of the differences in our physical structure, are all things we learn. He felt then that a girl could be raised to identify as and act like a boy and a girl could be raised to identify as and act like a girl. The Reimer’s allowed themselves to be convinced that it was in David’s best interest that they raise him as girl. They went forward with a surgery to remove his testes when he was 22 months.
David Reimer was born a twin. At birth he was named Bruce. His brother’s name was Brian. They were described as normal children; but apparently there was something strange in the way they urinated so their parents tried to fix that abnormality. That’s how the boys ended up receiving the circumcisions that left Bruce without a penis and lead the parents to consulting with Dr. John Money. No doubt the Reimer’s were doing what they thought was best for their son, but their decision would end up taking the ultimate psychological toll on both of their sons. Bruce who had lived as Brenda until age fourteen when he stopped identifying as female and named himself David, committed suicide in 2004 at the age of 38. His brother Brian had killed himself 2 years earlier.
Visit the following resources for more about the David Reimer Story








