If you, as an awkward high school student, ever found yourself the unwitting participant in a fistfight, be glad that you weren’t enrolled at South Oak Cliff High School in Dallas, Texas. There, former principal Donald Moten reportedly sanctioned “cage fights” between students. As a way of working out aggression between “troubled” youths, the fights were held in a steel equipment enclosure in the boy’s locker room. The contestants were not given any head gear, although the fights were said to have been monitored by a school security guard.
An internal report by the Dallas Independent School District (DISD) says that the fights went on between 2003 and 2005, although Moten, who resigned from the district in 2008 (more on that later) denies the accusations. Moten told The Dallas Morning News, “That’s barbaric. You can’t do that at a high school. You can’t do that anywhere. It never happened.”
But Moten, a former Dallas police officer, has a history of struggles with veracity, including once lying about being kidnapped and robbed in order to avoid going to work (he was placed on administrative leave). Moten was also embroiled in a grade-changing scandal (which led to his resignation) that forced the school to hand over its 2005 and 2006 state boys’ basketball championship titles.
The DISD found that Moten had pressured teachers to change athletes’ grades so that they would be academically eligible to play in the state championships. It was during that investigation that the district also uncovered the cage-fighting incidents. DISD Superintendant Michael Hinojosa has confirmed that there were “some things that happened inside of a cage.” Although criminal charges have not been filed, discipline has been taken, according to Hinojosa.
Apparently, the fights were common knowledge among staff and students, though no one spoke about them until the report was made public. Frank Hammond, a former South Oak Cliff counselor who has filed a whistle-blower lawsuit, said that he, too, was aware of the fights but did not report them because he knew that nothing would be done. He told The Dallas Morning News that the culture at the school, staffed by many South Oak Cliff alumnae and attended by their relatives, prevented action.
The New York Times’ coverage of the South Oak Cliff cage fights adds that school-sanctioned fistfights run counter to research within the last decade regarding conflict resolution in schools. Dr. Joan F. Goodman of the University of Pennsylvania School of Education told the Times, “Schools need to think much more carefully about how they can find outlets, socially appropriate outlets, for aggression. But to just go into a room and slug it out until someone wins, that’s obviously condoning violence, and the school has no business condoning violence. If kids think this kind of behavior is encouraged, it could spread.”